From Dockyard to Your Yard
The New York Times
December 19, 2002
By ALASTAIR GORDON
IF every object has its day, then the steel shipping
container may be the log cabin of the 21st century.
One winter morning in 1996, Ada Tolla and Giuseppe Ligano,
partners in the New York-based architecture firm LOT-EK,
left the city for an outing. Instead of driving to a ski
mountain or spa, they chose an unlikely destination, a port
in Elizabeth, N.J. There they walked among great ziggurats
of shipping containers that were stacked along the wharves.
What Ms. Tolla and Mr. Ligano saw in the industrial sprawl,
they said, was no less than a new kind of city. "You had
narrow streets and piazzas and incredible facades," Ms.
Tolla said. "It was the best architecture I had ever seen."
At the time, Mr. Ligano was less than convinced. Was it
really architecture?
"Yes," Ms. Tolla said. "For me it was like being in
Pompeii."
Since that day, Ms. Tolla, 38, and Mr. Ligano, 39, have
adopted the container as a design signature, using it along
with oil tanks, airplane fuselages and other industrial
castoffs. Their most recent project is an ingenious system
of movable containers for the Bohen Foundation, an
exhibition space that opened last month at 415 West 13th
Street (Ninth Avenue).
"We tend to use the most banal objects," Mr. Ligano said.
"It's all about the stuff around us that you see every
day."
LOT-EK (pronounced LOW-tech) is the most prominent of an
emerging school of architects using inexpensive recycled
containers as temporary or permanent homes, offices or
galleries. ( http://www.lot-ek.com )
Ms. Tolla and Mr. Ligano, childhood friends, grew up on the
same street in Naples. On their first visit to America, in
1989, they drove across the country, photographing
highways, gas tanks and malls along the way.
"In Italy, the burden of history is always with you," Ms.
Tolla said. "When we came here, it was like these doors
sprang open. Ah, there is also this modern world! We had
the realization that this was our true culture - these
colors, these shapes."
Ms. Tolla and Mr. Ligano returned to America the following
year and attended a postgraduate program at Columbia
University's Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and
Preservation. They have lived in New York ever since. Ms.
Tolla, whose companion is a photographer, had a baby in
August.
For Art Basel Miami Beach, an art fair held this month, 20
shipping containers were refurbished and converted into
galleries by a Basel architectural firm, Steinmann &
Schmid.
The containers were lined with white wooden walls and
positioned along the beach at Collins Park (not far from
the main exhibition at the Miami Beach Convention Center).
After the show closed, the containers were reused for their
initial purpose, transporting exhibition materials back to
Switzerland.
LOT-EK designed an exhibition for Art Basel, a video
lounge, which was installed at the Miami Public Library,
where viewers watched videos while lying down on a sloping
floor. "We call it a technological beach for image
bathing," Mr. Ligano said.
For designers with a weakness for industrial chic,
containers are hard to resist. They're a ubiquitous
byproduct of the global economy - available from Montana to
Mozambique - and endlessly recyclable. They stack as easily
as children's blocks and shift like Legos from truck to
ship to train. They come in an assortment of sizes and are
extremely durable. And they're inexpensive: a 40-foot-long,
8-foot-high container costs about $2,300.
"There's a kind of self-effacement in the attitude that not
everything needs to be designed from scratch," said Terence
Riley, chief curator of architecture and design at the
Museum of Modern Art in New York. "There's a thrifty and
environmental turn to the use of containers. It goes back
to the found object and the ad hoc-ism of the 1960's."
A New Jersey architect, Adam Kalkin, who has used
containers as instant rooms in several housing projects,
said he was attracted to containers for their enigmatic as
well as practical qualities.
"They have all of this veiled mystery," he said. "These
things have been sitting on ships all over the world,
carrying God knows what."
Mr. Kalkin used three stacked shipping containers in his
Collector's House, a $140,000 prototype for mass-produced
housing, built last year on the grounds of the Shelburne
Museum in Shelburne, Vt. Hope Alswang, president of the
museum, said that about 200,000 people had visited the
prototype. "Some were initially skeptical about the idea of
living in containers," she acknowledged. "But as they spent
some time inside it, they were transformed."
For a 4,000-square-foot vacation house in Brooklin, Me.,
Mr. Kalkin used 12 containers: two stacks of six each,
topped by a prefabricated roof. "People looked at us and
thought we were crazy," said Anne Adriance, an advertising
executive who owns the house with her husband, Matthew, a
business consultant. "But it's very intimate inside the
container rooms. It's cozy without being cloying."
The central living area of the house, which cost $500,000,
is an open, loftlike space. Five containers serve as
bedrooms, three as bathrooms. To relieve their monastic,
cell-like quality, Mr. Kalkin filled in opened ends of each
container with glass. "They have this total plastic
quality," he said, talking about the containers. "You just
take a welding torch and cut out a skylight or a window or
a door."
After initial complaints, the community has grown to accept
the unconventional structure, Ms. Adriance said. "It's so
far outside of people's context for `house' that they don't
have the emotional language to envision it. Their first
reaction is curiosity and confusion."
LOT-EK has pushed the container aesthetic to a new level of
sophistication at the Bohen Foundation, which asked the
architects to anticipate the needs of experimental artists.
We were looking for a firm that could reconceive the very
idea of the exhibition space and how it functions," said
Frederick B. Henry, president of the foundation.
Within the vast, 15,000-square-foot space, LOT-EK placed
eight bright red steel shipping containers, four of them
used as offices. One is a video lounge, another is a
conference room. Here and there, the corrugated metal has
been folded down like a flap to create desks or counters.
All the containers are mounted on steel rollers that slide
along tracks recessed a few inches into the concrete floor.
"As you move the containers you transform the space," Ms.
Tolla explained. "It's all about flexibility."
A set of overhead tracks, like those used in nearby
meatpacking plants, support generic white exhibit walls
that can be moved to create gallery enclosures. The result
is a kind of crazy railroad-switching yard. "There's a
sense of joy about working in such a nontraditional space,"
said Joan Weakley, Bohen's program director, who had been
working inside one of containers for the past two weeks.
"The possibilities are limitless."
Perhaps LOT-EK's most ambitious project to date is its
Mobile Dwelling Unit, a housing system inspired by a visit
that the partners made in 1999 to a container port in Red
Hook, Brooklyn, where they watched as a giant, insectlike
mechanism moved hundreds of containers from a ship to
waiting trucks.
Their dwelling unit is a self-contained space for living
and work, lined with built-in fixtures and furnishings made
of fiberglass, that is shipped as efficiently as any other
industrial container.
A prototype version of LOT-EK's Mobile Dwelling Unit is now
being fabricated and is to be part of a traveling
exhibition that starts at the Walker Art Center in
Minneapolis in June. "We are building it as a real
architectural product, not just a conceptual project," Ms.
Tolla said.
While container architecture might be another passing
design trend, it seems to be making at least some headway
into domestic reality. "You have to take a leap of faith,"
said Ms. Adriance, who will be moving into her container
house in Maine in a few weeks. "I am in the mood for it."