| Brokeback Mountain screenwriters Larry McMurtry and Diana Ossana spoke
briefly and answered audience questions after a late-January American
Film Institute screening of the film in Hollywood. Diana noted the
difficulty they had getting the film produced. Everybody loved the
screenplay, they had relatively little trouble securing financing and
directors, but they could never get two young actors to commit to
playing the roles of Ennis del Mar and Jack Twist. They'd send the
screenplay to a promising young actor, the actor would read it and
contact them immediately, excited about the project, and then slowly
drift away, never to be heard from again. Maybe the actors worried they
weren't up to the task. Maybe they had second thoughts about playing a
man in love with another man. Maybe their agents or handlers talked them
out of it. Whatever the case, this went on for the better part of a
decade. Larry & Diana never could get two actors to commit to the
project at the same time. Financing and directors came and went,
while the film remained unmade.
It might have stayed that way too, if it hadn't been for Jake
Gyllenhaal and Heath Ledger. With a screenplay so detailed, so
vivid and so moving, it was as though the film was already complete and
ready to be projected, only the projector didn't have a bulb. By
accepting the roles of Jack Twist and Ennis del Mar, these two actors
gave light to a film which had been lingering in darkness.
And their courage lit up more than just this film. Thousands of
men – and a startling number of women – have taken the time to
express online and in print how much seeing this film has impacted them,
how much it's meant to them, how deeply it mirrors the landscape of
their own lives. As one man put it, Brokeback Mountain was the first
time he's seen a love story in a theater where the projector was doing
all the projecting, instead of relying on him to do half of it.
For the hundreds of thousands - if not millions - of gay men living a
closeted existence, passing as straight in cities and towns across
America, Brokeback Mountain has done more than illuminate their
world. It also represents the first mirror Hollywood has ever
provided to reflect their love.
The film has also stirred up a storm of indignation from both
extremes of the culture wars. Elite religious fundamentalists are
horrified by the film's vivid portrayal of the lead characters as human
beings – instead of easily-vilified stereotypes – coping with the
corrosive culture of hate these same fundamentalist leaders actively
promote. Meanwhile, Hollywood gossip mongers and vicious media queens
have taken to dissecting every statement, every gesture Ledger &
Gyllenhaal have made in public, as part of a ridiculous,
holier-than-thou crusade to condemn any perceived homophobia on the part
of the two actors.
I'm sure there must be times when the two of them wonder what they
ever did to merit the shrill braying of so many asses. Like many
pioneers before them, they seem to be amassing quite the collection of
arrows in their backs.
These two young men didn't have to make this film. It was an
enormously risky move on their parts. Many prior dramas featuring
positive, frank depictions of gay romance and sexuality - such as 1982's
Making Love or the more recent Alexander - have tanked at the box office
and arguably damaged the careers of the actors involved. Had it
turned out Ledger and Gyllenhaal weren't capable of pulling off
realistic performances as lovers, had the direction or editing rendered
their work melodramatic or camp, the film - and these two actors - could
easily have been laughed out of theaters by gay and straight audiences
alike. Instead of an incredible $100 million (and counting) in global
box office, the film could have failed to recoup its $14 million
budget. Instead of Oscar nominations, Ledger and Gyllenhaal
could have been staring at Razzie nominations and ruined careers.
If Brokeback Mountain told some part of your own story or the story
of someone you love, if it made you look at your own experiences and
choices anew, if the performances impressed you or connected with you in
a way you hadn't experienced before, let the actors who gave life to
these characters know that. Let them know that their work has a meaning
to you beyond the Hollywood hype machine, beyond the media manipulators
and their manufactured controversies, beyond the box office and the
awards.
Send them a postcard. Just a simple postcard, perhaps featuring a
photograph of some local landscape or a favorite landmark, maybe your
own Brokeback Mountain. You can pick up a couple of cards at a gas
station along a highway, or at a shop near your local tourist haunts.
Some US post offices even have plain postcards, like the ones Ennis sent
in the film, sporting the new 24-cent postcard rate. Simply write
"Thank you" on each card – the same way Ennis wrote
"You bet" on his reply to Jack – sign your name, then
address one to Heath Ledger and one to Jake Gyllenhaal care of their
agency:
c/o CAA
9830 Wilshire Blvd.
Beverly Hills, CA 90212-1825
Heath and Jake seem like a couple of thoughtful, perceptive guys.
They had to be, in order to portray their roles in Brokeback Mountain
with such force and conviction. If they receive a bunch of
"Thank you" postcards from folks scattered around the globe
they should get the message loud and clear, and appreciate it the way so
many have appreciated this film and their enlightening work in it.
|